Hidden treasures discovered while digging through Frank Moore's huge archives.

Tag: Censorship (page 1 of 1)

THIS ISN’T AMERICA NO MORE

By Frank Moore, 1987

(AS READ ON KPFA RADIO 1987)

THIS ISN’T AMERICA NO MORE. NO HAND OF FREEDOM NO MORE. THE BILL OF RIGHTS HAS BEEN REPEALED. AND THERE ARE NO SCREAMING HEADLINES TO INFORM YOU OF THIS FACT. NO GAVEL-TO-GAVEL COVERAGE OF THIS COUP.

RADIO IS A CAVE OF IMAGINATION, OF DIRECT COMMUNICATION. WHEN I WAS A TEENAGER, I LAY ON MY BED AND SANG ALONG WITH THE RADIO. IN THE CAVE THAT RADIO CREATED IN MY SKULL, I WAS THE ROCKSTAR, SINGING ABOUT LOVE, SEX, REVOLUTION, IDEALS. THEN THE CAVE TURNED INTO A MULTICOLORED WINDOW OF UNCENSORED IDEAS AND WORDS, BITING SATIRES, ALLEN GINSBERG’S POEMS… MY MIND FLEW OUT OF THE WINDOW OF THE CAVE.

RECENTLY I WAS ON THE RADIO. I FELT LIKE I WAS IN THE CAVE AGAIN. BUT THIS TIME, I WAS IN THE CAVE OF THE MINDS OF MAYBE A COUPLE OF THOUSAND…JUST LIKE I AM IN YOUR MIND RIGHT NOW AS YOU ARE LYING THERE IN YOUR BED, OR DRIVING ON THE FREEWAY, OR PAINTING THAT MASTERPIECE, OR FIGHTING OFF BOREDOM AND LONELINESS ON THE NIGHTSHIFT. I COULD TALK TO, SING TO, PLAY WITH EACH LISTENER DIRECTLY IN THE CAVE OF THE MIND. I LIKED THAT INTIMACY. I LIKED WHEN A LISTENER CALLED IN, MAKING THE INTIMACY A CONCRETE TWO-WAY REALITY.

BUT NOW THINGS HAVE CHANGED SINCE THERE IS NO MORE AMERICA, NO MORE BILL OF RIGHTS…NO MORE RIGHTS TO FREEDOM OF SPEECH, OF RELIGION, OR OF PRESS. RIGHTS ARE THE KIND OF THING WHICH WE ALL TOTALLY HAVE OR NOBODY DOES. AS WE SPEAK, BIG BROTHER IS LISTENING IN. HE HAS BOOBY TRAPPED THE CAVE. ONE WORD THAT HE CAN CONSTRUE AS SEXUAL, OBSCENE, OFFENSIVE, IN BAD TASTE, OR OUTSIDE BOUNDS WHICH HE HAS NOT TOLD ABOUT YET, THEN THE CAVE WILL EXPLODE IN THE FORM OF KPFA AT FIRST…BUT THE EXPLOSION WILL REACH ALL THE FORMS OF THE CAVE BEFORE IT IS ALL OVER.

THE MOTIVE IS POLITICAL. BIG BROTHER SAYS IT IS TO PROTECT THE MINDS AND MORALS OF CHILDREN. HE LIES. IT IS TO PROMOTE THE UNREALITY OF FRAGMENTATION. BIG BROTHER DOES NOT LIKE GAYS. HE DOES NOT LIKE KPFA. BUT HE REALLY DOES NOT LIKE US GETTING TOGETHER AND REALIZING WE HAVE NOTHING TO FEAR FROM ONE ANOTHER…SO WE CAN WORK AND PLAY TOGETHER. KPFA IS OR WAS A PLACE WHERE THAT CAN HAPPEN. THAT IS WHY KPFA IS ONE OF THE FIRST TO GO. BIG BROTHER KNOWS BY CONTROLLING WHAT IS SAID, AND HOW IT IS SAID, HE CAN MAINTAIN HIS POWER. HE IS CREATING AN UNREALITY OF OUR SPEECH. IN THE REAL WORLD, FOUR-LETTER WORDS ABOUND, ESPECIALLY WHEN WE GET EMOTIONAL, WHEN WE FEEL DEEPLY AND STRONGLY. SUCH STRONG, DEEP EMOTIONS ARE SUBVERSIVE. SEXUALITY IS ONE OF THE STRONGEST HUMAN EMOTIONS. THIS IS THE REAL REASON FOR THIS CENSORSHIP.

BUT IT WAS NOT JUST BIG BROTHER AND THE RIGHT WINGERS WHO CREATED THE DOOR TO THIS THOUGHT CONTROL. WE DID OUR SHARE…BY TRYING TO BAN RACIST, SEXIST, HOMOPHOBIC, PORNOGRAPHIC, VIOLENT, OR WHATEVER OTHER KIND OF COMMUNICATED THOUGHT WE FIND OFFENSIVE. CENSORSHIP FOR WHATEVER PURPOSE IS WRONG. IT COMES FROM A BELIEF THAT PEOPLE ARE NOT CAPABLE OF FINDING THE TRUTH OR WHAT IS RIGHT ON THEIR OWN IN THE MARKETPLACE OF IDEAS. THIS IS THE BELIEF THAT THE INDIVIDUAL IS BASICALLY WEAK, FRAGILE, AND DUMB. A LISTENER IS NOT STRONG ENOUGH OR SMART ENOUGH TO TURN OFF WHAT OFFENDS HIM. CHILDREN ARE SO FRAGILE THAT A FOUR-LETTER WORD, A NUDE PERSON, A CONTROVERSIAL IDEA SEEN OR HEARD THROUGH THE MEDIA WILL SCAR THEM FOR LIFE. PARENTS AND TEACHERS CANNOT GIVE CHILDREN MORALS, ETHICS, AND BELIEFS AND IDEALS STRONG ENOUGH, TRUE ENOUGH TO SURVIVE AND GROW IN A FREE SOCIETY. PARENTS ARE NOT CAPABLE OF GIVING THEIR CHILDREN EFFECTIVE MORAL GUIDANCE IN A FREE SOCIETY. THESE ARE THE BASIC BELIEFS FROM WHICH CENSORSHIP SPRINGS.

WHAT ALSO IS CONTAINED IN CENSORSHIP IS A BASIC BELIEF THAT TRUTH AND WHAT IS RIGHT DO NOT WIN EVENTUALLY IN THE FREE MARKETPLACE OF IDEAS. WE CANNOT PRESENT ATTRACTIVE ALTERNATIVES TO WHAT WE THINK IS WRONG…ATTRACTIVE ALTERNATIVES THAT PEOPLE WILL GRAB HOLD ONTO. INSTEAD, WE DESTROY THE FREE MARKETPLACE OF IDEAS BECAUSE WE DO NOT TRUST OURSELVES, OUR IDEALS, OR OTHER PEOPLE.

AND BIG BROTHER LAUGHS AS RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS ARE BEING TAKEN AWAY.

TONIGHT WE CAN SING TOGETHER NONVERBALLY IN A STATE OF RAPTURE NOT CONNECTED TO ANYTHING SEXUAL OR OBSCENE. CALL IN AND SING WITH ME.

WE CAN TALK ABOUT BUILDING A CAVE OF OUR OWN…A CAVE THAT BIG BROTHER CANNOT CONTROL…BECAUSE THIS CAVE IS MAGICALLY LOW TECH AND SMALL. THIS IS WHAT MY ART IS ABOUT. I AM LOOKING FOR PEOPLE TO PLAY WITH IN THIS CAVE. CALL IN.

WE CAN HAVE FUN.

CALL IN.

Censorship Address to the Berkeley City Council

Written September 8, 2002.

City Council member Kris Worthington, Frank Moore and Dr. Susan Block

Hi. I am Frank Moore, the producer/host of the targeted UNLIMITED POSSIBILITIES and the sponsor of the targeted SUSAN BLOCK SHOW. It is interesting that this proposed ordinance is designed to target shows by an uppity crip and a smart sexy woman…or is it a smart sexy crip and an uppity woman? My show is politically, culturally, and artistically radical, offering in-depth conversations about issues that affect us all with a wide range of people, live music, and cutting-edge performances, films, and art. We throw everything in this stew for social change, explore everything, including eroticism, to find alternatives. This is what got me targeted by Sen. Jesse Helms in the early ’90s. And this is why our shows are being targeted now. A few people, including some on the City Council, want to sweep these alternatives from public access because they are threatened by these alternatives.

Councilmember Betty Olds, who introduced this ordinance, has publicly proclaimed that if she had her way, she would ban these alternatives from our public access channel. She bemoaned the fact that it is illegal to censor or ban community shows on public access channels. This ordinance is an attempt to get around this legal fact. Olds actually has said she would take away B-TV, the channel of the community, if that was the only way she could force the removal of the shows that she doesn’t approve of. So the real targets and victims of this ordinance are not our two shows, but the people of Berkeley, their freedom of expression on their channel.

This ordinance came about when both the staff of B-TV and the board of BCM refused to adopt a censoring scheduling policy, following their mission of promoting free speech and diversity. They knew getting some complaints is always a part of running a free speech channel. All of us producers were acting responsibly, requesting that our shows be aired after 10pm, the standard “safe harbor” for adult content. But the City Council, fueled by very few complaints, decided to ignore B-TV’s staff and producers and the BCM board. It decided to issue rules controlling what could be shown on B-TV when. When politicians do this, it should always set off loud alarm bells.

This ordinance is a dangerous product of this misguided adventure. It purports to protect children from “indecent” programs. It doesn’t do this. Again Olds has admitted that protecting children is just an excuse to get rid of shows that she and people like her find unsettling, etc.. This ordinance does not provide cheap hardware to concerned parents that allow them to block any program they deem unfit for their kids. Instead, it does away with the “safe harbor” of the 10pm-6am timeslot for adult programming. In its place there will be an “indecent” timeslot of midnight to 6am. Except for the shows which fall into a very narrow definition of what “indecent” is as defined in this ordinance, all other shows can be shown anytime! As Councilmembers Spring and Maio pointed out as they voted against the ordinance, the two targeted shows are not indecent. In fact, B-TV doesn’t have any shows that are indecent as defined in this ordinance.

In reality, this ordinance is not about protecting children at all. It is about chilling free speech. It is about forcing people to do “acceptable” shows. Under this ordinance, a producer is expected to label her show as indecent or not. If she doesn’t label it as indecent and somebody complains, there is a hearing. This hearing, its process, its rules, etc. are not remotely spelled out in the ordinance. If the show is found “indecent” in the hearing, the show is exiled to after midnight. But if the show is found not to be indecent…well, the complainer can do it again next week…until the producer is ground down into watering down her program. This is the real goal of this ordinance, not protecting kids!

Well, Suzy and I are not chillers. We do not chill. We boil. If this ordinance passes, we will fight lustfully! And we will win. We have to because, as Kriss Worthington keeps pointing out, this would give this and other city councils the power to control what we do and say on OUR public access channels…and freedom of speech dies!

By the way, are we going to let them limit our possibilities?

The complete archive of the censorship battle is here:
https://www.eroplay.com/fmup/archive/censorship.html


This piece was published in
Frankly Speaking: A Collection of Essays, Writings & Rants.